What is a Restaurant Loyalty Program and How to Create One?

Why do certain restaurants consistently draw crowds and enjoy loyal customers? The answer often lies in well-crafted loyalty programs. These initiatives go beyond serving delicious food; they build a bond between the restaurant and its patrons, encouraging repeated visits and fostering a sense of belonging.

Restaurant loyalty programs are designed to create a rewarding experience for diners, turning casual customers into enthusiastic regulars. They offer tangible benefits like discounts, exclusive offers, or redeemable points that add value to each visit. For restaurant owners, these programs are an opportunity to engage customers more deeply and grow their business effectively.

As the restaurant industry evolves, loyalty programs are becoming an essential part of delivering satisfaction, one meal at a time.

The current state of the restaurant industry in the USA

In 2023, fast-food establishments in the United States earned an impressive $292.73 billion, marking a 7.2% compound annual growth compared to the preceding year. Over 50 million Americans eat fast food daily, underscored by the immense popularity of this dining choice within the nation.

The US holds a prominent position as the primary market for Quick Service Restaurants (QSRs), which have expanded globally, boasting major players in nearly every country.

Foremost among these is McDonald's, with a staggering presence of over 40 thousand outlets across 119 nations. With ambitious plans to surpass 50,000 locations by 2027, McDonald's dominance in the fast food sector is further reinforced by its substantial market value of $216.5 billion in 2023.

Nevertheless, amidst fierce competition, brand strategists are compelled to innovate to distinguish their offerings. Hence, many restaurant brands endeavor to captivate customers through the implementation of customer loyalty programs and digital platforms. Notably, each of the QSRs to be discussed later in this discourse features its own mobile application.

The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic acted as a catalyst for the digital transformation of QSR loyalty programs, precipitating the proliferation of delivery channels. Leveraging their proficiency in omnichannel operations, fast food proprietors navigated the challenges of lockdowns adeptly, ensuring customer retention and sustaining robust sales figures.

What is a restaurant loyalty program?

A restaurant loyalty program is a marketing strategy for restaurants designed to encourage repeat business from customers by rewarding them for their loyalty. 

These programs typically involve customers signing up for a membership or loyalty card, which allows them to accumulate points, earn rewards, or receive discounts based on their purchases at the restaurant.

Here's how it typically works:

• Membership sign-up: Customers enroll in the loyalty program either through a physical loyalty card or digitally through an app or website.
• Earning points: Customers earn points for every purchase they make at the restaurant. The number of points earned usually corresponds to the amount spent.
• Reward tiers: As customers accumulate points, they can reach different reward tiers. Higher tiers often come with more significant rewards or perks.
• Redeeming rewards: Customers can redeem their accumulated points for rewards such as discounts on future purchases, free meals, exclusive offers, or merchandise.
• Special promotions: Restaurants may offer special promotions or bonuses to loyalty program members, such as double points days or birthday rewards.
• Data collection: Loyalty programs also provide restaurants with valuable data about their customers' preferences, spending habits, and frequency of visits, which can be used to tailor marketing efforts and improve customer satisfaction.

Restaurant loyalty programs aim to foster a sense of appreciation and connection with customers, ultimately leading to increased customer retention and revenue for the restaurant.

An example of a restaurant loyalty program

One of the best restaurant loyalty programs examples is Joe's Pizzeria, a quaint Italian eatery. The owners want more people to come and enjoy their delicious pizzas. So, they decide to start a loyalty program to thank their loyal customers. This program will give rewards to people who keep coming back for more pizza. They want everyone who loves their pizza to feel like part of their big pizza family. 

Here is how they can go about it:

Joe's Pizzeria Loyalty Club

• Joining the club: When you first visit Joe's Pizzeria, you can sign up for their loyalty club. You might get a free slice of pizza just for joining!
• Earning points: You earn points every time you buy something at Joe's. For instance, you might earn 1 point for every dollar you spend. So, if you spend $10, you get 10 points.
• Redeeming rewards: Once you've collected enough points, you can trade them in for rewards. For example, 50 points might get you a free pizza slice, and 100 points might get you a free pizza.
• Special perks: As a loyalty club member, you might get extra perks like a free dessert on your birthday or special discounts that regular customers don’t get.

Benefits for customers

• Savings: You save money by getting free food or discounts.
• Special offers: You get access to deals that other customers don’t.
• Personal touch: The restaurant might send you personalized offers based on what you like to order.

Benefits for Joe’s Pizzeria

• Repeat business: Customers are more likely to keep coming back.
• Customer data: The restaurant learns about your preferences and can serve you better.
• Word of mouth: Happy customers might tell their friends about the great rewards, bringing in more business.

Why it works

People love feeling rewarded and appreciated. By joining a loyalty program, you not only get to enjoy your favorite food but also get bonuses for being a regular customer. For the restaurant, it means building a steady, loyal customer base.

Best restaurant loyalty program examples 

Here are the best restaurant loyalty program examples:

1. Hut Rewards from Pizza Hut

Customers earn points for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for free pizzas, sides, and desserts. Members also get access to exclusive deals and birthday rewards.

2. Subway MVP Rewards

Customers earn tokens for every purchase, which can be redeemed for discounts on future orders. Members also receive bonus offers and personalized deals.

3. Chick-fil-A One 

Members earn points for every purchase, which can be redeemed for free food items. They also receive member-exclusive rewards and birthday treats.

4. Starbucks Rewards

Starbucks Rewards offers points for every purchase, which can be redeemed for free drinks and food items. Members also receive personalized offers and freebies on their birthdays.

5. MyMcDonald’s Rewards

MyMcDonald’s Rewards allows customers to earn points for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for free food items. Members also receive exclusive offers and promotions.

6. Wendy's Rewards

Wendy's Rewards offers points for every purchase, which can be redeemed for free food items. Members also receive exclusive offers and discounts.

7. Chipotle Rewards

Chipotle offers a loyalty program in which customers earn points for every dollar spent, which they can redeem for free food. They also offer special bonuses and rewards, like free chips and guac, on certain occasions or for completing specific challenges.

8. MyPanera Rewards

MyPanera Rewards allows customers to earn points for every purchase, leading to free bakery items, beverages, and discounts. Members also receive personalized offers and sneak peeks at new menu items.

8 Best restaurant loyalty program ideas

Here are 8 best restaurant loyalty program ideas that you can consider implementing if your business is struggling.

1. Item-based rewards

• Free appetizers or desserts: Offer a free appetizer or dessert after a certain number of visits to your restaurant. For example, after every 5 visits, the customer gets a free dessert.
• Buy One, Get One Free: After several purchases, offer a "buy one, get one free" deal on specific menu items. This encourages customers to try more items on the menu and come back more often.

2. Incentives for promotion

• Referral bonuses: Reward customers who bring their friends to your restaurant. If a customer refers to a friend who joins the loyalty program, both the referrer and the friend get a discount or a free item.
• Social media sharing: Give rewards to customers who share their dining experience on social media and tag your restaurant. This could be a discount on their next meal or a free item, helping to promote your restaurant to a wider audience.

3. Subscription rewards

• Monthly meal plans: Offer a subscription service where customers pay a monthly fee and receive a set number of meals or special discounts. This ensures regular business and provides customers with good value for their money.
• Special access: Provide subscribers with early access to new menu items, special events, or exclusive deals. This makes them feel valued and gives them a reason to maintain their subscription.

4. Online incentives

• Online ordering discounts: Offer a discount to customers who place their orders through your restaurant’s website or app. For example, give a 10% discount on their first online order.
• Digital punch cards: These cards use an app to track visits and purchases. After a certain number of online orders, customers can earn a free item or discount, similar to a traditional punch card but more convenient.

5. Point-based rewards

• Points for every purchase: Give customers points for every dollar they spend at your restaurant. For example, earn 1 point for every dollar, and after collecting 100 points, they can redeem them for a free meal or discount.
• Bonus points: Offer extra points for certain actions, like ordering specific items, visiting during off-peak hours, or celebrating their birthday at your restaurant. This encourages more frequent visits and higher spending.

6. Free delivery

• Free delivery for members: Provide free delivery for loyalty program members on orders over a certain amount. This makes it more attractive for customers to join your program and order regularly.
• Exclusive delivery deals: Offer special discounts on delivery orders for loyalty members, such as a percentage off their total bill or a free item with their order. This encourages customers to choose your restaurant for their delivery needs.

7. Experiential rewards

• Cooking classes: Invite loyal customers to exclusive cooking classes where they can learn how to make their favorite dishes from your menu. This creates a memorable experience and strengthens their connection to your restaurant.
• Chef’s table experience: Offer top-tier members a special dining experience with the chef. They can enjoy a unique meal prepared just for them, which makes them feel special and appreciated.

8. Secret menu

• Exclusive items: Create a secret menu with special dishes or drinks that only loyalty program members can order. This adds a sense of exclusivity and makes members feel like they’re part of an insider’s club.
• Limited editions: Offer limited-time dishes or drinks that are available only to loyalty members. This can generate excitement and encourage more people to join your loyalty program to access these special items.

Best practices for designing a restaurant loyalty program

Here is how to design a successful restaurant loyalty program.

1. Understanding your customer base

To design a successful restaurant loyalty program, it's crucial to understand your customer base. This involves analyzing their preferences, demographics, and spending habits. By understanding what motivates your customers, you can tailor your loyalty program to meet their needs better and increase engagement.

2. Choosing the right rewards and incentives

The rewards and incentives you offer play a significant role in the success of your loyalty program. Choosing rewards that are valuable to your customers and align with your brand is essential. This could include discounts, free items, exclusive offers, or VIP experiences. By offering meaningful rewards to your customers, you can encourage repeat visits and build loyalty.

3. Marketing and promoting the program effectively

A key aspect of designing a successful restaurant loyalty program is effectively marketing and promoting it to your customers. This could include using email marketing, social media, in-store signage, and other channels to promote the program and encourage sign-ups. It's also important to regularly communicate with your members and keep them engaged with the program.

4. Continuously evaluating and adjusting the program

To ensure the success of your loyalty program, it's important to evaluate its performance and make adjustments as needed continuously. This could involve analyzing customer feedback, tracking program metrics, and identifying areas for improvement. By staying proactive and making adjustments based on customer feedback and data, you can ensure that your loyalty program remains effective and continues to drive customer loyalty

Case studies

Here are 2 case studies of businesses that have successfully implemented a restaurant loyalty program.

1. Chipotle rewards program 

Chipotle Mexican Grill, often simply called Chipotle, has established itself as a prominent player in the fast-casual dining scene, particularly in the United States. Known for its focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients and customizable menu options, Chipotle has garnered a loyal following since its inception. 

Here is how loyalty rewards company  helped Chipotle to significantly enhance the digital transformation through innovative modifications to their CRM and loyalty programs. The goal was to grow the Chipotle Rewards membership and boost digital ordering, resulting in impressive growth from 8 million to 32 million members in just two years.

Challenges

Before the initiative, Chipotle shifted its business model towards digital engagement to adapt to changing consumer behaviors and expectations.

The existing loyalty program did not incentivise repeat visits or engage users meaningfully.

There was a need to utilize customer data better to create personalized experiences and enhance customer retention.

Solutions

The loyalty rewards company redesigned the loyalty program to make it more engaging. They introduced the Rewards Exchange, which allows members to redeem points for food, gear, or charity donations.

To further incentivize customer behavior, "Extras" were introduced. These badges reward customers for digital ordering, frequent visits, or participating in special events such as the Boorito.

Leveraging deeper customer data, the program began offering more personalized journeys triggered by specific customer behaviors to predict and react to shifts in their engagement.

Results

The membership base grew impressively from 8 million to 32 million within two years.

The introduction of personalized rewards and interactions based on customer behavior and preferences led to a 724% ROI on key campaigns.

The new program structure led to over 28.7 million reward redemptions, indicating high customer engagement and satisfaction.

2. Pancheros' "Burritos with Benefits" rewards program

Pancheros, a popular Mexican grill, implemented its "Burritos with Benefits" rewards program to enhance customer retention and engagement using the Punchh platform. This case study explores the challenges faced, the solutions implemented, and the results achieved through this initiative.

Challenges

Pancheros faced several key challenges:

As consumer behavior shifted towards online ordering, Pancheros needed to enhance its digital presence to meet customer expectations and remain competitive.

Strengthening customer loyalty was crucial, especially in the competitive fast-casual dining market.

Effectively using collected customer data to personalize marketing efforts and improve the customer experience was a significant challenge.

Solutions

To address these challenges, Pancheros implemented several strategic solutions:

By integrating the Punchh platform, Pancheros enhanced its loyalty program, allowing for better customer data analysis and targeted marketing strategies.

Pancheros introduced a dedicated mobile ordering line and integrated digital promotions to facilitate and encourage online ordering.

The loyalty program was revamped to include more personalized rewards, leveraging customer behavior data to offer tailored promotions.

Results

The implementation of these solutions led to impressive results:

The retention rate soared to 47% in Q3 2023, significantly above the industry benchmark of 33%.

Loyalty sales saw a 15.16% increase year-over-year, demonstrating the enhanced effectiveness of the loyalty program.

The loyalty program's participation rate reached 23% in Q3 2023, indicating a higher level of customer engagement.

Enhance restaurant loyalty programs with Loyalife

Transform your restaurant into a hub of loyalty with Loyalife. Craft personalized programs that reward guests for visits, spending, or special occasions like birthdays. Drive repeat visits with targeted promotions, such as discounts on favorite dishes or exclusive rewards for frequent diners. Use advanced analytics to understand customer preferences, enabling tailored offers that keep patrons coming back for more. Seamless omnichannel integration ensures a unified experience across in-dining, takeout, and delivery services.

Key benefits for restaurants:

• Personalized rewards: Delight customers with tailored incentives, from meal discounts to exclusive dining experiences.
• AI-powered insights: Leverage data to optimize menus, plan campaigns, and understand dining trends.
• Extensive rewards marketplace: Offer gift cards, unique dining experiences, and more to keep your program fresh and engaging.
• Secure operations: Protect your loyalty program with fraud management tools, including points capping and transaction monitoring.

Conclusion

Restaurant loyalty reward programs have proven to be a powerful tool for building lasting relationships with customers and driving consistent business growth. By offering meaningful rewards, personalized experiences, and exclusive perks, these programs create a sense of appreciation that keeps patrons coming back. 

They not only enhance customer satisfaction but also provide valuable insights into preferences and behaviors, enabling businesses to refine their offerings. For restaurants, loyalty programs are more than just a marketing strategy—they are a pathway to fostering genuine connections, increasing retention, and ensuring long-term success in a dynamic industry.

FAQ's