On this page

In an ever-evolving marketplace, customer reward programs are crucial for fostering loyalty and driving sales. A recent survey of 1,477 sales professionals revealed key benchmarks: the average sales win rate is 21%, the close rate is 29%, and 91% of sales pros engage in upselling, which contributes 21% of company revenue. Notably, 87% of sales professionals also cross-sell, adding another 21% to revenue. These statistics underscore the importance of effective customer engagement and reward strategies. As businesses navigate increased competition and changing consumer preferences, innovative reward programs can play a pivotal role in maintaining customer satisfaction and boosting sales performance.

What are customer rewards programs?

A customer rewards program is a strategy designed to retain customers by incentivizing them to continue purchasing from your brand rather than switching to a competitor. These programs often reward customers with points, discounts, or exclusive benefits based on their purchasing behavior.

The History of Customer Rewards Programs: Key Eras and Lessons

18th to 20th Century: "Spend and Get" model

  • 1793: The first rewards program began with American merchants giving out copper tokens to repeat customers, redeemable for merchandise.
  • Late 19th to Late 20th Century: Copper tokens evolved into stamps, boxtops, and coupons, popularized by brands like Betty Crocker.

1980s: The birth of modern rewards programs

  • 1981: American Airlines launched the first modern rewards program, American AAdvantage, offering free flights for miles flown, which revolutionized customer rewards.
  • 1980s: The concept expanded to hotels, banks, credit card companies, and retailers, allowing detailed customer data collection and personalized marketing.

2000s to Present: Mass customer rewards approach

  • Early 2000s: Introduction of mobile communications, the Internet, and social media enabled coalition rewards programs where points could be earned and redeemed across brands.
  • Challenges: Coalition programs struggled in the U.S., often resulting in poor customer insights and engagement due to transactional focus rather than relationship building.

New tech paradigms & data security concerns

  • 2010s: Increasing consumer awareness of data security, leading to regulations like GDPR and CCPA, limiting data access for personalized rewards programs.
  • Digital Voice Assistants: Platforms like Alexa and Google Voice intermediated brand-customer relationships, shifting customer data control away from brands.

Personalization of rewards

  • Modern Insights: Personalized experiences and rewards are crucial. Customers prefer brands that understand their preferences and provide relevant, timely rewards.
  • Future Outlook: Successful programs must anticipate customer needs, protect privacy, and offer meaningful, personalized experiences and rewards.

Lessons for the future

  • Customer-centric design: Rewards programs should focus on enhancing customer experiences and rewarding Rewards meaningfully without making customers prove their Rewards.
  • Responsive adaptation: Programs need to adapt to market changes, offer greater privacy protection, and provide personalized rewards and experiences to maintain relevance and effectiveness.

Innovative customer reward program ideas

1. Points-based programs

STARBUCKs: Starbucks' success is significantly attributed to its exceptional Rewards program, Starbucks Rewards, launched on December 26, 2009. With over 30 million active members, the program contributes nearly 60% of Starbucks' total revenue. In 2019, it drove a 7% sales increase, highlighting its impact.

Program structure

Points System

  • Earn 1 Star per $1 spent (cash).
  • Earn 2 Stars per $1 spent (preloaded card).
  • Bonus Stars through promotions and Delta Airlines partnership.
  • Points expire after 6 months.

Rewards

  • 25 Stars: Free customizations.
  • 50 Stars: Complimentary coffee, tea, or bakery items.
  • 150 Stars: Handcrafted drink or hot breakfast.
  • 200 Stars: Lunch item.
  • 400 Stars: Packaged coffee beans or merchandise.

Coalition rewards

  • Delta Airlines Partnership: Double Stars on travel days and 1 mile per $1 spent at Starbucks. 

Insights

Delta Airlines has leveraged strategic partnerships to enhance its point-based customer reward program, SkyMiles. Notably, Delta’s collaboration with American Express has been pivotal.

This partnership allows SkyMiles members to earn bonus miles on everyday purchases and provides exclusive benefits such as priority boarding and free checked bags. According to Delta's reports, SkyMiles has over 100 million members, and the program contributes significantly to customer retention and engagement.

2. Tiered rewards programs

SEPHORA: The Sephora Beauty Insider Rewards program features a tiered system with escalating benefits based on spending. It includes:

  1. Insider: Free to join, earning 1 point per dollar spent, with access to the Beauty Insider Community, free classes, and birthday gifts.
  2. VIB (Very Important Beauty Insider): Requires spending a certain amount annually, offering more points, monthly gifts, early access to sales, and enhanced birthday gifts.
  3. Rouge: The highest tier, providing the most points, free shipping, exclusive events, and premium birthday gifts.

Key Rewards

  • Rewards Bazaar: Redeem points for curated products.
  • Seasonal Promotions: Discounts, double-point events, early sale access.
  • Birthday Gifts: Exclusive options for higher tiers.
  • Beauty Insider Community: Platform for tips and engagement.
  • Beauty Classes: Complimentary classes on makeup and skincare.
  • Free Samples: More samples for higher tiers.
  • Exclusive Events: Access to brand launches and influencer meet-and-greets.
  • Custom Makeovers: Free makeovers for higher tiers.
  • Exclusive Product Access: Early or exclusive product access for top tiers.

3. Subscription-based programs

AMAZON PRIME: Amazon Prime's US membership reached 180 million in March, an 8% increase from last year, showcasing its strong appeal despite competition and economic challenges.

Key takeaways

Membership Growth:

  • 180 million US members, 75% of US shoppers.
  • 8% year-over-year increase.

Benefits:

  • Fast delivery, shipping discounts, Prime Video.
  • $140 annually or $15 monthly.

Competition:

  • Continues to attract new subscribers despite rivals like Walmart, TikTok Shop, Shein, and Temu.

Pandemic Recovery:

  • Growth flattened post-pandemic but is now increasing.

Household Sharing:

  • Subscriptions often shared within households.

Financial Impact:

  • 200 million global members in 2021.
  • Projected 12% increase in subscription revenue to $10.8 billion.

Impact and Conclusion

Amazon Prime's reward program thrives with valuable benefits and strong consumer appeal, contributing significantly to Amazon’s revenue and maintaining its vital role in the company's strategy.

4. Gamified rewards programs

NIKE: Nike's gamified Rewards program, NikePlus, has significantly boosted customer engagement and brand Rewards through interactive and rewarding experiences.

Key Features

  • NikePlus Membership: Offers personalized workout plans, exclusive access to products, and priority checkout.
  • Nike Training Club App: Provides custom training programs, tracking progress, and earning badges for completing challenges.
  • Exclusive Rewards: Members can earn rewards such as early product access and invitations to exclusive events.

Impact

  • Membership Growth: Over 170 million members worldwide.
  • Increased Engagement: Members are more active, leading to higher purchase frequency and brand Rewards.

5. Value-based programs

PATAGONIA: Patagonia, renowned for its outdoor apparel and gear, is equally famous for its unwavering dedication to environmental and social responsibility. Central to this commitment is its Value-Based program, which sets a precedent in the corporate world by prioritizing ethics over profit.

Core values

  • 1% for The Planet: Since 1985, Patagonia has donated 1% of sales to environmental preservation, contributing over $140 million. In 2002, Patagonia's founders created the non-profit 1% for the Planet to encourage other businesses to do the same. This alliance commits 1% of annual sales to grassroots environmental causes, fostering corporate responsibility and gaining support from eco-conscious consumers.
  • Fair Trade and Ethical Sourcing: The company ensures fair labor practices and transparency in its supply chain. As of 2023, 88% of its line uses recycled or reclaimed materials.
  • Political Activism: Beyond business, Patagonia engages in political advocacy. It famously sued the Trump administration over the reduction of national monuments, demonstrating its commitment to preserving public lands.
  • Impact and Success: Patagonia's Value-Based program not only shapes its brand identity but also drives significant business success. Despite its emphasis on sustainability, the company reported $1.5 billion in revenue in 2023, marking a 10% year-over-year increase.

Conclusion: In the competitive landscape of retail and outdoor gear, Patagonia stands out not only for its innovative products but also for its unwavering commitment to ethical practices and environmental sustainability. Through its Value-Based program, Patagonia continues to set the standard for corporate responsibility, proving that profitability and principles can coexist harmoniously.

6. Community-driven programs

REI Co-op (Recreational Equipment, Inc.): REI Co-op is a well-known U.S. company that has implemented a successful community-driven rewards program. REI's Co-op Membership program is designed to engage its community of outdoor enthusiasts while fostering a strong sense of loyalty and support for outdoor activities and conservation efforts.

Key Features of REI’s Community-Driven Rewards Program:

  • Lifetime Membership: For a one-time fee of $30, members receive a lifetime REI Co-op membership.
  • Annual Dividend: Members earn an annual dividend of 10% back on eligible purchases, which can be used towards future purchases.
  • Exclusive Discounts: Members have access to special sales events and discounts on gear, clothing, and services.
  • Community Involvement: REI promotes outdoor activities by organizing events, classes, and outings that members can participate in.
  • Environmental Stewardship: REI invests in the outdoors through grants and partnerships with local and national organizations to support conservation projects.

Conclusion: By emphasizing community involvement and environmental stewardship, REI’s Co-op Membership program not only rewards its members but also strengthens their connection to the brand and its values.

7. Cashback programs

Bank of America Preferred Rewards: Bank of America (BoA) stands out with its innovative Cashback Program, adding value to everyday transactions and prioritizing customer satisfaction.

Core components:

  1. Cash Rewards Credit Card: Offers 3% cash back in a chosen category, 2% at grocery stores/wholesale clubs, and 1% on other purchases. Customers earned over $1 billion in rewards in 2023.
  2. Preferred Rewards Program: Enhances cashback by 25% to 75% based on the customer’s relationship with the bank.
  3. BankAmeriDeals: Offers additional cashback through personalized deals with retailers, earning customers millions in extra cash back.

Impact and Success: In 2023, the Cashback Program led to a 15% increase in active credit card accounts and a 20% rise in customer retention.

Conclusion: Bank of America's Cashback Program rewards customers for everyday purchases and enhances benefits for loyal clients, showcasing the bank's commitment to delivering value.

8. Spend based programs

THE BODY SHOP: The Body Shop's Love Your Body Club is a spend-based Rewards program that rewards customers and promotes social and environmental causes.

Core components:

  1. Points System: Earn 10 points for every $1 spent. Every 100 points = $10 reward. Over 5 million members redeemed rewards in 2023.
  2. Exclusive Benefits: Enjoy birthday gifts, early sales access, and personalized offers, boosting member engagement by 30%.
  3. Community and Sustainability: Donate points to charitable causes. In 2023, $500,000 worth of points were donated.

Impact and Success: In 2023, the program led to a 25% increase in repeat purchases and a 15% rise in sales.

Conclusion: The Love Your Body Club rewards loyal customers and supports meaningful causes, driving engagement and sales.

9. Free perks programs

GRUBHUB+: Grubhub+ enhances the food delivery experience with exclusive benefits for members.

Core Components:

  1. Unlimited Free Delivery: Free delivery on orders over $12, saving members an average of $120 annually.
  2. Exclusive Perks and Rewards: Discounts, special offers, and 10% cashback on eligible orders, boosting member orders by 25%.
  3. Donation Matching: Matches donations made through Donate the Change, raising over $2 million in 2023.

Impact and Success: In 2023, Grubhub+ led to a 30% increase in membership and a 20% rise in order frequency.

Conclusion: Grubhub+ offers unlimited free delivery, exclusive rewards, and community support, driving customer Rewards.

10. Hybrid programs

DICK’s SPORTING GOODS SCORECARD: Dick’s Sporting Goods, a leading retailer of sports equipment and apparel, has launched a Hybrid Program that combines in-store and online benefits to enhance the shopping experience and reward loyal customers.

Core Components:

  1. ScoreCard rewards program: Members earn 1 point for every $1 spent. For every 300 points, they receive a $10 reward. In 2023, over 20 million members redeemed rewards.
  2. ScoreRewards credit card: Offers 2 points per $1 spent at Dick’s stores and online, plus exclusive financing options. This has increased cardholder spending by 35%.
  3. Online and in-store integration: Members enjoy benefits like free shipping on online orders and access to special in-store events. This hybrid approach has led to a 25% increase in online sales and a 15% boost in in-store traffic.

Impact and success: The Hybrid Program has significantly boosted customer Rewards and sales. In 2023, it contributed to a 20% increase in total revenue and a 30% rise in membership.

Conclusion: Dick’s Sporting Goods Hybrid Program seamlessly combines in-store and online benefits, rewarding customers and driving engagement.

These examples showcase a variety of approaches to customer Rewards programs, each tailored to the specific needs and behaviors of their customer base. By aligning program benefits with customer preferences and leveraging technology for personalization and engagement, businesses can create compelling Rewards programs that drive long-term customer Rewards and revenue growth.

Key elements of successful reward programs

Financial incentives wield tremendous influence in motivating health plan participants to seek high-quality, cost-effective care. Once you've selected and acquired a rewards program, launching it successfully requires meticulous planning. Here are five essential steps to ensure a successful start:

  1. Define clear objectives and goals: Set clear objectives with measurable metrics to facilitate outcome assessment. Assign responsibilities for each goal, schedule regular progress checks to maintain momentum, and identify critical milestones for agile adjustments.
  2. Build the right team for success: From the beginning, engage key stakeholders across various functions. This includes crafting targeted messaging strategies through Marketing and Communications to achieve program objectives, strategically managing campaign budgets with Finance, implementing robust measurement frameworks for tracking program efficacy through Analytics, and ensuring compliance and addressing program implications proactively with Legal. This collaborative approach ensures alignment and effectiveness across all aspects of the rewards program implementation.
  3. Know your audience: Create detailed member personas based on healthcare behavior, demographics, and health needs, then strategically customize incentives to effectively and sustainably drive desired behaviors.
  4. Establish program guidelines: Ensure clarity in your rewards program by first defining clear eligibility criteria for participation. Next, structure the program's duration and format, whether ongoing or segmented, to meet your goals effectively.

    Set transparent qualification criteria for rewards that align with service selections, and articulate any restrictions and potential tax implications clearly to members. Provide a detailed framework outlining the rewards and recognition participants can expect, ensuring transparency and understanding throughout.
  5. Plan clear and continuous communication: To ensure the success of your rewards program, begin by creating anticipation and engagement through a strong pre-launch communication strategy, which includes email campaigns, targeted promotions, and informative website content. Throughout the program's lifecycle, maintain regular communication to validate member actions and reinforce positive behavioral changes continuously.

    It's crucial to avoid pitfalls such as failing to deliver promised incentives, using the program to distract from other changes, introducing overly complex terms, or ending the program abruptly without proper notification to members. Consistent and clear communication builds trust and enhances member satisfaction throughout the rewards program journey.

Tips for implementing your customer reward program

1. Understand your customers

  • Customer Segmentation: Use data to segment your customers based on purchasing behavior, preferences, and demographics. This allows you to tailor rewards to different customer groups.

2. Offer relevant and valuable rewards

  • Provide rewards that resonate with your customers. For instance, Sephora's Beauty Insider program offers personalized beauty products and exclusive access to events, which has significantly increased customer retention.

3. Simplify the earning and redemption process

  • Ensure that earning and redeeming rewards is straightforward. Starbucks' Rewards program allows customers to earn stars for purchases and redeem them easily through their app, leading to a 20% increase in customer spending.

4. Leverage technology

  • Integrate your Rewards program with a mobile app to enhance accessibility and engagement. Walgreens' Balance Rewards program is accessible via their app, contributing to a 50% increase in active program members.

5. Promote your program effectively

  • Use various marketing channels to promote your Rewards program. Nike's marketing efforts for NikePlus, which include personalized content and exclusive offers, have boosted member engagement by 40%.

6. Monitor and adjust your program

  • Regularly analyze program performance and gather customer feedback to make necessary adjustments. Amazon Prime continually updates its benefits based on member feedback, resulting in a 90% retention rate in the US.

7. Foster a sense of community

  • Offer exclusive perks and experiences to create a sense of belonging. The North Face's XPLR Pass gives members access to exclusive products and events, driving a 60% increase in member purchases.

8. Incorporate gamification

  • Use gamification to make the Rewards program more engaging. Microsoft's Xbox Rewards uses a gamified system to keep users engaged, resulting in higher participation rates.

9. Focus on personalization

  • Tailor rewards and communication-based on individual customer behavior. Nordstrom's Rewards program, The Nordy Club, uses personalized offers to increase member spending by 20%.

By understanding your customers, offering valuable rewards, leveraging technology, and continuously monitoring and adjusting your program, you can implement a successful customer reward program that boosts engagement and Rewards.

Giift: Transforming customer reward programs

GIIFT is leading the way in advancing customer reward programs, offering innovative solutions that enhance engagement and Rewards. By leveraging advanced technology and strategic insights, GIIFT helps businesses create tailored reward experiences that resonate with customers.

Key benefits and features:

  1. Personalization: GIIFT enables businesses to personalize reward offerings based on customer behavior and preferences, driving higher redemption rates and customer satisfaction.
  2. Advanced analytics: Utilizing robust analytics tools, GIIFT provides actionable insights into customer spending patterns and program effectiveness, helping businesses optimize their reward strategies.
  3. Multi-channel integration: GIIFT supports seamless integration across multiple channels, including mobile apps and online platforms, ensuring accessibility and convenience for customers.

Discover how GIIFT can elevate your customer reward program and drive business growth. Visit GIIFT for more information or schedule a demo with our Rewards expert.

Conclusion

Customer reward programs have evolved significantly from their origins in the 18th century with copper tokens to today's sophisticated tools for enhancing customer Rewards and engagement. Modern programs like Starbucks' points-based rewards, Sephora's tiered Beauty Insider program, and Amazon Prime's subscription model cater to diverse customer preferences, fostering deeper brand connections through personalized experiences and exclusive benefits. 

Initiatives by Nike and Sephora illustrate the power of community engagement, boosting Rewards and brand reputation. Successful programs integrate mobile experiences, gamification, and personalized rewards, driving customer satisfaction and sales. These strategies not only support retention and revenue growth but also enhance brand advocacy in today's competitive marketplace.